What to expect from online message boards
Message boards and discussion groups (which now include Twitter) are an excellent way to engage with people who have similar interests and for this reason, book publicists often encourage authors to explore and participate in appropriate online venues. But message board newbies would be wise to note that online companions don’t always play nice. Let me provide an example. (And no, this example does not involve a certain South by Southwest panel going, well, south.)
About a year ago, shortly after Katie Holmes finished the New York City marathon in just under five-and-a-half hours (putting her in the bottom 15 percent of women her age), I made an admittedly rude comment on a running message board about Suri probably being able to crawl that fast. I also found fault with the commonly-held notion that marathons are somehow the gold standard of fitness (I think being, well, fit is the gold standard of fitness — whatever “fit” means to an individual) and said I thought marathons — a supremely unnatural 26.2 miles of exertion — should be reserved for faster, fitter runners. In an all-that-matters-is-you-crossed-the-finish-line age, this did not go down well.
Let me share with you a few gems from the comment thread (but before I do, let me just say, sic, sic and sic):
“Thanks, sweety, for insulting all 5 hour marathoners.”
And file this one under Bang-Head-Against-Brick-Wall:
“You can attempt to explain yourself as much as you want, but you are still wrong.”
And the crowning glory:
“… you’re basically a d**k … you simply need to STFU!!!!! Anything else will make you look like a bigger idiot than you’re already coming off as.”
For those of you unschooled in the ways of online abbreviations and wondering what “STFU” means, let me just hint that the first and last words are “shut” and “up.” I think you can fill in the blanks. Of the 56 other comments, about 55 averaged somewhere between indignant and condescending.
Although message boards do attract people of similar interests, this online interaction provides a shield of anonymity, which some interpret as a license to be rude. In the most extreme cases, “trolls” incite “flamewars.” (In this instance, I’m not sure I’d classify the commenters as trolls — who deliberately seek to be contrary or cruel — or simply as semi-literate.)
Another feature of message boards you should keep in mind is that only a fraction of people who read them ever comment. (Readers who never comment are known as “lurkers.”) So there might have been 59 comments to my Rude Comment About Katie Holmes, but the message thread garnered more than 17,000 views. Yes. 17. Thousand. Keep this in mind if you’re a blogging author who fears no one reads your posts. And if you’re someone who reads message boards but doesn’t comment, give it a whirl. You’re interested enough in the topic to visit the site — why not interact with others who share your views (or who don’t share your views)? Make yourself heard (preferably once you know the style and tone of the group).
For every wacky person out there, there are many who participate in ideological rather than personal debates, whose arguments are measured and sound and professional. Whose views are enlightening and from whom you can learn. These are the people with whom you should engage for informative and productive discourse. As for the others, ignore them. Then wait and make fun of them on your blog.
Have you had any particularly good (or atrocious) experiences with message boards? Do share.
March 31, 2009 - Posted by Yen | Discussion Groups, Miscellaneous | commenting, message boards
8 Comments »
Leave a reply to Silapolxxzz Cancel reply
About
Fall 2012: I’ve really enjoyed writing about book publicity and meeting (0nline and in person) writers, publicists, editors, agents and others in the publishing industry, but I’ve — reluctantly — come to the conclusion that I just don’t have the time to maintain this blog.
I imagine there is some information that will remain the same and that will remain useful, but there is much more that is or will become out of date, so please keep that in mind if you find yourself perusing my posts.
Yen
*****
For some time now, I’ve closely followed a lot of very informative sites about media and about the publishing industry. Since I find myself quite voluble at times about issues that pertain to my job in the publicity department at a large publishing house, I thought I’d set up a book publicity blog. The purpose of this blog is provide tips, primarily, but also information about publishing / marketing trends that will help book publicists — and hopefully others in media and publishing — do our jobs with greater ease and efficiency. Please note that the opinions expressed on this blog are my own, not those of my company.
I encourage you to subscribe to my feed in an RSS reader, but you can also receive a daily newsletter with content from this blog. See below for subscription options or for information about how to follow me on Twitter.
Happy pitching.
Yen
Categories
Archives
Book Blogs
- Beatrice
- Birdbrain(ed) Book Blog
- Blog of a Bookslut
- Book Bench
- Book Group Buzz
- Book Reader’s Heaven
- Book Room
- BookDaddy
- Bookdwarf
- BookFox
- Bookgasm
- Bookmarks Literary Blog
- Bookninja
- Bookreporter.com Blog
- Books & Booze
- Books Covered by Tobias
- Books Inq.: The Epilogue
- Books on the Brain
- BookTrib
- Chekhov’s Mistress
- Confessions of an Idiosyncratic Mind
- Conversational Reading
- Critical Mass
- Dibs!
- Edward Champion’s Reluctant Habits
- Elegant Variation
- Fernham
- Follow the Reader
- Fresh Eyes Now
- Happy Booker
- Hey Lady! Whatcha Readin’?
- Jacket Copy
- Kenyon Review Blog
- Largehearted Boy
- Literary Kicks
- Literary Rapture
- Literary Saloon
- Litter in Littérateur
- Mark Athitakis’ American Fiction Notes
- Maud Newton
- Moby Lives
- Mumpsimus
- Off the Page
- Off the Shelf
- Old Hag
- Omnivoracious
- Paper Cuts
- Pinky’s Paperhaus
- Rake’s Progress
- re: Print
- Reading Experience
- Reading Room
- Reading Under the Covers
- Ready Steady Book
- Sentences
- Shaken & Stirred
- Short Stack
- Texas Pages
- Three Guys One Book
- Three Percent
- Tingle Alley
- Tor.com
Bookstore Blogs
Future of Publishing Blogs
Literary Agent / Editor Blogs
- Agent in the Middle
- Ask the Agent
- Book Cannibal
- Book Deal
- Bookends LLC — A Literary Agency
- Dystel & Goderich Literary Management
- Editorial Anonymous
- Editorial Ass
- Et in arcaedia, ego.
- Evil Editor
- Fine Print Literary Management
- Guide to Literary Agents
- Janet Reid, Literary Agent
- Knight Agency
- Lyons Literary LLC
- Nathan Bransford — Literary Agent
- Pub Rants
- Query Shark
- Rants & Ramblings
- Rejecter
- Swivet
- WEBook Blog
- Writer Beware Blogs!
Marketing / PR Blogs
Media Blogs
Miscellaneous Blogs
Publishing Blogs
Publishing House Blogs
- 26th Story
- 33 1/3
- Abbeville Manual of Style
- Algonquin Books Blog
- Amistad
- Arsenalia
- Beacon Broadside
- Best Words in Their Best Order
- Chronicle Books
- Countryman Press Blog
- CruelestMonth.com
- David R. Godine
- Different Stripe
- Doubleday
- Duke University Press
- Gibbs Smith Books Blog
- Good Books in Bad Times
- Harvard University Press Publicity
- Hesperus Press
- Illinois Press Book Blog
- Newmarket Press Blog
- Norton_Fiction on Twitter
- OUP Blog
- papressblog
- Penguin Blog
- Picador
- Random House Library Services
- Sarabande Books
- Seal Press
- Soft Skull News
- Springboard Press
- Suvudu
- Tarcher Blog
- The Winged Elephant
- Wingéd Elephant
- Yale Press Log
Technology Blogs
Top Posts
I’ve had good and bad experiences with message boards. When I was pregnant, the group I belonged to was a lot of fun and very informative. After I had my daughter and moved into a playgroup message board, there were constant flame wars and attacks that seemed to be generated by members who would assume a new, anonymous identify and go on a tirade against other members. I finally left the group for good because their tactics were unpleasant and I was no longer learning anything or having fun.
My truly positive experience was on a scrapbooker’s group. I learned a lot, even met several members in person for crops and – amazingly enough – made a friend who referred me for my current job with Author Marketing Experts. It’s been almost six years, so clearly that experience worked out very well! It also shows that you just never know who you can meet online. Proceed with caution in the beginning, but it is possible to make friends and invaluable contacts.
Comment by Paula Krapf | March 31, 2009 |
Have had some really strange reactions on group message boards on Linkedin. I’ll chalk it up to the high number of unemployed folks and the stress this must be placing on their “online” manners 🙂
Comment by Barbara Kimmel | March 31, 2009 |
As a new novelist, I recently followed Steve Weber’s advice (in “Plug Your Book”) on seeking good reviewers: “You can find prospective reviewers by posting a message on Amazon’s discussion board dedicated to customer book reviews:
http://forums.prosperotechnologies.com/n/mb/listsf.asp?webtag=am-custreview
I posted a polite inquiry and waited, naively thinking that I would receive an email message from anyone interested. A few weeks went by and it occurred to me that perhaps I had to check back with the discussion board for replies. I checked. There were over 250 entries by then. The very first one had been a casual nasty, “yeah, I’ll give you a bad review…” and the pitbulls moved in. I was called a panhandler, a kook, and became the source of lots of fun for a few mean-spirited nitwits. Others entered the fray trying to defend my inquiry or turn around the tone of the thread. It finally petered out at about 450 comments. It was a mortifying and fruitless effort. Lesson learned: take the time to figure out the tone and rules of engagement before jumping blindly into any message board group; they can become as tight a club as a beehive, and prone to sting an unexpected stranger.
Comment by Mara Feeney | March 31, 2009 |
I am in agreement with the author on Mrs. Tom Cruise’s NYC Marathon performance. She should have stayed in bed instead of going for a five hour walk. Why not go shopping instead? What did she prove? How “unathletic” her jaunt was? It’s hard enough getting into the “circus” that is run the first
Sunday in November, I’m sure many who can run much faster than five
hours were in shock: how did she get a number anyway?
Comment by Jerode King | April 1, 2009 |
I don’t know who Katie Holmes is, but completing a marathon in 5 1/2 hours is not bad at all.
That is far better than most people are able to do.
Good for Katie Holmes, whoever she is.
Comment by John | July 24, 2009 |
Hi guys,
My computer worked slowly, too much mistakes and buggs. Please, help me to fix buggs on my computer.
My operation system is Windows XP.
With best regards,
Reovireence
Comment by Reovireence | December 18, 2009 |
Hello !
I’m new on this forum so I introduce me…
My name is Jason I’m 27 years old, I’m French.
I like: holdem poker and baseball…
Nice to meet you
Comment by Silapolxxzz | October 20, 2010 |
Guy .. Beautiful .. Superb .. I will bookmark your website and take the feeds alsoI am happy to seek out numerous useful info right here in the post, we’d like work out extra techniques on this regard, thank you for sharing. . . . . .
Comment by soarinciniash | September 23, 2011 |